PAPEPPE
‹ Blog

Mindset

The Secret, without the magic: what actually helps

5 min read · Updated

By Pieter & Jolanda Visser

A man on a seaside bench looking at a calm sea, notebook beside him

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • There is no evidence that thoughts alone make things happen, as The Secret claims.
  • Picturing a goal does make it clearer and keeps it in mind.
  • Only fantasising about success led to less effort and worse results in Oettingen's studies.
  • Picture the result, then the obstacle, then make an if-then plan: that's WOOP.

In 2006, a book and film called The Secret told millions of people that their thoughts shape their lives. Picture what you want, believe it, and it will come to you. Vision boards became one of its best-known tools.

Twenty years later, you might still have one. Maybe it helped a little. Maybe it didn't.

Here's an honest look at what picturing your goals does, what it doesn't, and how to use the good part.

Dream big. Then plan small.

What does The Secret say?

The Secret, by Rhonda Byrne, is built around the "law of attraction": like attracts like. Focus on what you want with strong feeling, and you draw it into your life.

The book is full of stories from people who say it worked for them. What it doesn't have is evidence that thoughts alone change what happens around you. No study has shown that.

But that's not the end of the story. Some parts of the idea do hold up, just for different reasons.

What does picturing your goal do well?

  • ✅ It makes a goal clear. You can't picture a vague wish. Picturing forces you to decide what you want.
  • ✅ It keeps the goal in mind. What you see every day stays on your radar. You notice chances you'd otherwise miss.
  • ✅ It feels good. A photo of a place you love lifts your mood for a moment.

That's real. It's also not magic. It's attention.

PAPEPPE

Everything in sight. On one board.

Tasks, notes, photos and plans as cards on one calm board. No charge today. Cancel anytime.

Start 7 days freeOr see all templates →

What can go wrong with only dreaming?

Psychologist Gabriele Oettingen has studied this for more than 20 years. Her findings surprise most people.

In one study with Doris Mayer, she followed students looking for their first job. The ones who fantasised most positively about landing a great job sent out fewer applications, got fewer offers and earned less than the others.

In another study, with Heather Barry Kappes, positive fantasies actually lowered people's energy.

Why? A happy picture can feel like a reward you've already had. You relax. The work feels less urgent.

What works better than only dreaming?

Oettingen found a simple next step. After you picture the result, picture what stands in your way. Then make a plan for it.

She calls it mental contrasting. Combined with an if-then plan, it became the method WOOP: Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan. We explain it step by step in WOOP: turn wishes into plans.

It's still a dream. It just comes with a plan for Tuesday.

How do I combine the dream and the plan?

Put both on one board, side by side.

The picture keeps you wanting it. The goal card tells you what to do next.

Does believing in my goal help at all?

The feeling behind "believe it" can help. Believing a goal is possible matters.

Oettingen's work shows that mental contrasting works best when people think they have a real chance. When the odds are good, naming the obstacle makes people commit harder. When a goal really isn't reachable, it helps them let go and choose a better one. Both are useful.

So believe it's possible. Then plan for the hard part.

A simple daily routine

  1. Morning: look at your vision board for ten seconds.
  2. Then: read your goal card and pick one step for today.
  3. Evening: tick it off, or move it to tomorrow.

Ten seconds of dreaming, one step of doing. That's the whole "secret".

What does it look like on one board?

A few dreams with a photo and one line each, and a goal card that turns the biggest one into steps. The dream and the plan, in one look.

A vision board in PAPEPPE: the dream, and the goal card that turns it into steps.

The honest version of The Secret

Screenshot this.

  1. Picture what you want. One photo, one line.
  2. Picture what's in your way.
  3. Write an if-then plan for it.
  4. Pick one step for today.
  5. Look at it every morning.
Tonight, look at your biggest dream and write down what's really in the way.

Questions

Does the law of attraction work?

There is no scientific evidence that thoughts alone change what happens around you. Picturing a goal can still help by making it clear and keeping it in mind.

Is visualisation bad for reaching goals?

Only picturing a happy result can be. In Oettingen's research, people who fantasised most positively put in less effort. Picturing the obstacle as well works better.

What is mental contrasting?

Picturing the result you want and then the main obstacle in your way. Research by Gabriele Oettingen found it helps people commit to goals they can reach.

How do I use a vision board without the magic?

Put each dream next to a goal card with a date, milestones, the obstacle and an if-then plan, and pick one step each day.

Who wrote The Secret?

Rhonda Byrne. The book and film came out in 2006 and made the law of attraction and vision boards widely known.

Sources

  1. The Secret — official site
  2. Oettingen, G., & Mayer, D. (2002). The motivating function of thinking about the future: Expectations versus fantasies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 83(5), 1198–1212.
  3. Kappes, H. B., & Oettingen, G. (2011). Positive fantasies about idealized futures sap energy. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 47(4), 719–729.
  4. Oettingen, G., Pak, H., & Schnetter, K. (2001). Self-regulation of goal setting: Turning free fantasies about the future into binding goals. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 80(5), 736–753.
  5. WOOP and mental contrasting — Gabriele Oettingen

Try it on your own board.

No charge today. Cancel anytime.

Start 7 days free